Skip to content
All insights

Buying & Selling

How is a property’s asking price determined?

A comparative market analysis is not a magic formula. Here is how a broker analyses comparable sales, adjusts for differences, and arrives at a realistic price range.

5 min readSeptember 28, 2026Information article published on johncharles.caLire en français
Broker analysing real estate market data

Pricing a property for sale is one of the most important decisions in a real estate transaction. Too high and you extend the timeline and may be forced into concessions. Too low and you leave money on the table. Here is how a broker arrives at a well-founded recommendation.

The comparative market analysis (CMA)

The primary tool is the comparative market analysis — an analysis of recent sales of comparable properties in the same area. It is not an automatic formula. It is an exercise in judgement that requires understanding why some properties sold at a given price and others did not.

Comparables: how to select them

An ideal comparable is a property similar to yours — same type (single-family, duplex, condo), same area, similar approximate size — sold within the last six to twelve months. The more recent and geographically close the comparable, the more relevant it is.

What makes two properties comparable:

  • Property type (single-family, plex, condo)
  • Living area and number of rooms
  • Area and street (location can make a significant price difference, even within the same neighbourhood)
  • General condition and year of construction
  • Presence of a garage, yard, or parking

The adjustments

No two properties are identical. The broker adjusts comparable prices to account for differences. A comparable property with a garage is worth more than yours without one — the broker subtracts the estimated value of the garage from the comparable's sale price to obtain a fair basis for comparison.

These adjustments are subjective and based on local market experience. This is where knowledge of the area makes a real difference.

What the CMA cannot do

The CMA gives a probable price range — not a precise figure. The market decides the final price. A well-prepared, well-marketed, and correctly priced property can sell above the range if several buyers are interested simultaneously.

A broker's comparative market analysis is not an appraisal by a certified appraiser. It is also different from the municipal assessment, which is established for taxation purposes and does not necessarily reflect current market value.

Factors that influence price beyond comparables

  • Market conditions at the time of listing (seller's or buyer's market)
  • Season (spring generally generates more activity)
  • Quality of marketing (photos, description, visibility)
  • Property preparation (decluttering, small repairs)
  • Flexibility on the possession date

Why the listing price is strategic

The listing price influences buyer perception and the number of showings. A property listed too high generates few showings and may stay on the market long enough for buyers to wonder why it has not sold. A subsequent price reduction is less effective than a good starting price.

The goal is not to sell as quickly as possible at any price — it is to maximise the net proceeds of the sale within a reasonable timeframe. These two objectives are not always in tension, but they require a considered strategy.

Thinking of selling?

A few questions about your property, then a personalized profile of the factors that influence its value. You can then request a comparative market analysis, if you wish.

Get my property profile

Or contact me directly

Share this article