Key takeaways
- Location, evolution over time, and the presence of water are more useful factors than width alone when assessing a crack.
- Some cracks are common in concrete foundations and do not require immediate action.
- Others may indicate structural movement or an infiltration problem that warrants investigation.
- Only a structural engineer can assess the structural significance of a crack.
- When a sale is handled by a broker, known cracks must be disclosed in the seller’s declaration.
Why not all cracks are equivalent
Concrete foundations are subject to cracking for various reasons: shrinkage during initial curing, seasonal soil movement, differential settlement, hydrostatic pressure, or structural movement. Not all of these causes present the same level of concern.
The most useful factors for guiding an investigation are not the crack width, but rather: its location (wall, slab, corner), its orientation (vertical, horizontal, diagonal), the presence of displacement or offset between the two edges, its evolution over time (stable or progressive), and the presence of moisture or infiltration.
A fine, stable crack in a poured concrete foundation wall is often the result of normal material shrinkage. A horizontal crack in a concrete block wall, or a crack with visible displacement, warrants different attention.
What you can observe
- Vertical, diagonal, or horizontal cracks in foundation walls
- Cracks in the basement concrete slab
- Visible displacement or offset between the two edges of a crack
- Moisture traces, efflorescence (white deposits), or active infiltration around a crack
- Cracks in interior partitions or around openings (doors, windows)
These observations guide the investigation but do not allow conclusions about the cause or the need for intervention.
What observation cannot establish
- The cause of the crack (shrinkage, movement, pressure, etc.)
- The structural significance of the crack
- Whether the crack is stable or progressing
- The necessity, nature, or urgency of intervention
A photograph is not sufficient to assess a crack. Evolution over time, context, and the overall foundation are needed for an informed assessment.
Information to gather
- The seller declaration, which must mention any known cracks and their history
- Any existing building inspection or engineering report
- Previous repair work (nature, date, contractor)
- Year of construction and foundation type (poured concrete, blocks, stone)
- History of basement water infiltration
Relevant professionals
Structural engineer: the only professional qualified to assess the structural significance of a crack and recommend corrective measures if needed.
Building inspector: can note and describe observed cracks but does not conduct structural assessments.
Foundation specialist contractor: can evaluate repair options once a diagnosis has been established by an engineer.
John Charles is a real estate broker. He can direct you to the right professionals but does not conduct technical assessments.
Questions to ask
Relevant questions
- Does the seller declaration mention cracks? Is their history documented?
- Has repair work been done? When, by whom, and with what warranty?
- Has there been water infiltration associated with the cracks?
- Has an engineer assessed the cracks? Is a report available?
- How long have the cracks been stable?
Considerations for buyers and sellers
For buyers: if cracks are present or mentioned, an assessment by a structural engineer before purchase is a reasonable step. Your broker can advise on a protective clause.
For sellers: all known cracks must be disclosed. Having a recent engineering report and documentation of previous work facilitates the transaction and reduces uncertainty during negotiations.
Frequently asked questions
Sources & references
- Ordre des ingénieurs du Québec — Find an engineer — To identify a qualified structural engineer
- OACIQ — Seller declaration — Disclosure obligations in Quebec
Related articles
Let’s talk about your real estate project.
Get in touch