Some backfill placed under the concrete slabs of houses in Québec contains pyrite. Here is what to understand, which signs may justify an expert assessment, what happens next, and which professionals to consult.
This article provides general information only. It is not legal or technical advice and does not replace the advice of an engineer, geologist, building inspector, notary or lawyer. A real estate broker cannot diagnose the presence of pyrite.
Key takeaways
- Pyrite is a mineral found in some granular backfill placed under concrete slabs. The risk depends on the materials used and how each building was constructed, not on its address.
- In contact with moisture and oxygen, pyrite can oxidize and trigger reactions that make the backfill swell and lift or crack the slab.
- A visit, even by a building inspector, is not enough to confirm or rule out pyrite. Only an assessment of the backfill can evaluate the situation.
- The legal warranty, seller disclosure, warranty exclusions and broker obligations are separate concepts. To find out what applies to your sale, consult a notary or lawyer.
What is pyrite in a real estate context?
Pyrite (iron disulphide, FeS₂) is a mineral found in some rocks. The real estate problem comes from granular backfill containing pyrite placed under concrete slabs, especially in basements and garages.
When this backfill is exposed to moisture and oxygen, pyrite can oxidize and produce sulphuric acid. The acid reacts with carbonates in the backfill, notably calcite, to form gypsum. The growth of gypsum makes the backfill swell, which can lift, crack or deform the slab.
The extent of the problem depends in particular on the nature of the backfill and on the moisture and oxygen available. Damage may appear several years after construction.
Pyrite and pyrrhotite: two different problems
Pyrrhotite is also an iron sulphide. According to the Régie du bâtiment du Québec (RBQ) and the OACIQ, as it crystallizes it can cause cracks in the concrete itself. This is a separate problem from pyrite in the backfill under the slab, and it also calls for professional advice.
An address alone does not determine the risk
Pyrite problems depend on the backfill used and on how the building was constructed. A property’s location can neither establish that it is affected nor rule it out. The year of construction is not enough either.
What you can observe
During a visit or an inspection, some observations may justify an expert assessment:
- cracks in the basement or garage slab;
- visible heaving or deformation of the slab;
- cracks in the foundations or in partition walls;
- mention of a test or expert assessment in the seller’s declarations.
These observations do not confirm pyrite: other causes, such as settlement or drainage problems, can produce similar signs. Their absence does not rule pyrite out either.
The expert assessment and its results
According to the OACIQ, the assessment should be entrusted to a recognized laboratory and includes a visual examination of the damage, sampling and analysis of the backfill. Swelling potential is expressed in particular by the petrographic index of the sulfatic swelling potential (IPPG), described in standard BNQ 2560-500.
Results must be interpreted by qualified professionals, taking into account the actual condition of the building. A laboratory result, on its own, does not indicate whether work is needed, and results can vary from one laboratory to another.
After a potential problem is identified
When a pyrite-related problem is suspected or identified, the process generally includes:
- an assessment by qualified professionals;
- interpretation of the laboratory results and technical findings;
- an evaluation of the actual condition of the building (slab, foundations, walls);
- written recommendations from qualified professionals;
- corrective work, if any, based on those recommendations.
Not all findings lead to the same measures. The nature, duration and cost of any work can only be specified by the professionals and contractors consulted. For any work, hire a contractor holding an RBQ licence.
For a new house or condo covered by the guarantee plan for new residential buildings, the RBQ states that the guarantee ends five years after completion of the work and that meeting the deadlines is very important to assert your rights.
Information to gather
- The seller’s declarations, including any tests or expert assessments performed.
- Any existing expert report: date, laboratory, professionals who performed or signed the report, conclusions and recommendations.
- Invoices and records of previous work on the slab, basement or foundations.
- The year of construction and any available information on the backfill used.
Legal warranty, disclosure and obligations: what to distinguish
These concepts are often confused. They are presented here in general terms; how they apply depends on the facts, the contract and how the courts interpret them.
- Seller’s declarations: the seller must act in good faith. When a seller signs a brokerage contract to sell a principally residential building with fewer than five dwellings (excluding divided co-ownership), the mandatory Seller’s Declarations form asks, among other things, to the best of the seller’s knowledge and in good faith, whether tests or expert assessments have been done (pyrite is among the examples) and whether problems have affected the soil or foundations. Deliberately hiding a known problem or making an inaccurate declaration can have serious legal consequences.
- Legal warranty of quality: the seller is bound to warrant that, at the time of sale, the property is free of latent defects that make it unfit for its intended use or so reduce its usefulness that the buyer would not have bought it or would not have paid so high a price had the buyer known of them. The warranty does not cover a defect the buyer knew of, or an apparent defect, meaning one a prudent and diligent buyer could notice without needing to call on an expert (art. 1726 of the Civil Code of Québec).
- Warranty exclusions: the parties may limit or exclude the warranty, but a seller can never exclude liability for its own personal acts or omissions (art. 1732). Nor can a seller exclude or limit liability without having disclosed the defects it knew of or could not have been unaware of and that affect the right of ownership or the quality of the property; an exception may be made where the buyer buys at its own risk from a non-professional seller (art. 1733).
- Buyer’s checks: because the warranty covers neither known nor apparent defects, what the buyer learns before the sale, through an inspection, an expert assessment or the seller’s declarations, can change the buyer’s position. It is therefore important to carry out the appropriate checks before committing.
- Discovering a defect after the purchase: the buyer must give the seller written notice of the defect within a reasonable time after discovering it. When a defect appears gradually, the time runs from when the buyer could have suspected its seriousness and extent. A seller who knew of the defect or could not have been unaware of it cannot rely on late notice (art. 1739). The law sets no fixed number of days.
- When to consult: a notary or lawyer before signing a promise to purchase or a deed that includes a warranty exclusion, and promptly if you discover a defect after the purchase; a qualified professional for any technical question about the backfill, slab or foundations.
A broker is neither an engineer nor an inspector and does not give an opinion on the cause of cracks. Under OACIQ regulations, the broker must, among other things, take reasonable steps to discover adverse factors, inform the parties of those he or she is aware of and, where their interests require it, recommend that they consult a recognized expert.
John Charles is a real estate broker, not an engineer. He can direct you to the right professionals but does not conduct technical assessments.
For buyers
If observations, the seller’s declarations or an existing report suggest a problem, or if no expert assessment has been done, talk to your broker, before signing a promise to purchase, about the checks to plan (pre-purchase inspection and, if needed, a backfill assessment) and how to protect your interests. According to the OACIQ, the buyer, not the broker, decides whether the results of an assessment are acceptable. For any legal question, consult a notary or lawyer.
If the sale is made without legal warranty at the buyer’s own risk, your remedies may be significantly limited, including against previous owners. Consult a notary or lawyer before committing.
For sellers
With a broker, complete the Seller’s Declarations form to the best of your knowledge and in good faith, and provide any available reports and invoices.
With or without a broker, if you are considering limiting or excluding the legal warranty, consult a notary: a warranty exclusion is governed by the Civil Code and does not, by itself, settle the question of disclosure. A recent expert report can make discussions with buyers easier.
Frequently asked questions
Sources & references
- Régie du bâtiment du Québec — Pyrite and pyrrhotite
- OACIQ — Pyrite and pyrrhotite — Practice guide
- OACIQ — High-risk areas for pyrite: Broker responsibilities
- OACIQ — Seller’s Declarations on the Immovable — Mandatory form (French)
- Regulation respecting brokerage requirements, professional conduct of brokers and advertising (CQLR, c. C-73.2, r. 1) — French text
- Civil Code of Québec, arts. 1726, 1732, 1733 and 1739 — LégisQuébec
- Géologie Québec — ET 2003-02
- Bureau de normalisation du Québec — BNQ 2560-500
Related articles
Let’s talk about your real estate project.
Get in touch